Last year at PRI in Person, I asked participants about the future of the Principles for Responsible Investment.
For a reason I can’t quite put my finger on, that conversation faded a bit this year – at least in conversations I had.
Perhaps expectations reset? Or the PRI saw the fruits of its engagement with the critiques levelled against it?
No, this year my conversations had a different protagonist: job loss.
And it’s time we talked about it. Because we are failing each other.
Based on my conversations, it seems our industry sorts neatly into four categories, like those pseudo-scientific colour personality tests, in terms of how we engage with people who have lost their job.
One person described the first profile as “treating unemployed people like lepers”. Beelining away as if unemployment were contagious, or at the very least so socially useless that any time spent with the unemployed is wasted time.
The second profile is the professional equivalent of the “voyeur”, treating tales of job loss as gossip fodder and a source of satisfaction that they had been spared (so far).
For the voyeur, interest and participation may at first glance look like empathy. But really, more often than not, they just reflect an almost Kunderian vertigo, intrigued by the “voice of the emptiness below us which tempts and lures us”.
I’d call the third profile “see no evil, speak no evil”. They will quickly steer the conversation away from the individual to the adoption rate of transition plans, or the importance of nature and the just transition in designing climate strategies.
“Be an ally. Because it’s obvious from my conversations that too many of us are not.”
A kind interpretation of this profile is that this is out of empathy, of not trying to put focus on the other person’s unfortunate circumstance. A rude interpretation is that they just don’t want to face the music the industry is dancing to.
The final profile in the anecdotes I’ve heard is the hero of the story, at least at first glance: the “ally”.
The ally says something like: “Don’t hesitate to reach out! Let me put you in touch with somebody! Have you seen this job offer?”
(In case folks are wondering, I, of course, am the ally, because I have an all-round pleasant and generous personality free of vices and sins.)
Ok, back to my four personalities.
There is an easy message here. Check yourself. Be less of a voyeur! You’re not a leper colony warden! Your gentle sustainability soul needs to sometimes hear some cold, hard truths!
Be an ally. Because it’s obvious from my conversations that too many of us are not.
This is easy advice. The hard part of these conversations involved trying to figure out what that means, to be an “ally”.
Kind words are a start. I admit I don’t have that much first-hand experience. I am what a headhunter recently called me (who may or may not have founded a financed emissions data provider in a previous life): a “lifer” (he added for good measure that it made me basically “unemployable” – great news!).
In moments of crisis, kind words matter. But they are not enough.
But I remember in 2021 looking at the prospect of unemployment. My board decided to file for bankruptcy after a research partner chose not to distribute the funds received on our behalf from a funder.
It was kind words that helped me through some pretty dark weeks (as it happened, the research partner relented and we didn’t file).
But I remember the feeling. In that moment, I needed the kind words of an ally.
After all, to borrow a quote from Julia Roberts’ Vivian in the ’90s rom-com classic Pretty Woman: “people put you down enough, you start to believe it”.
In moments of crisis, kind words matter. But they are not enough.
How many of us are putting in the work behind the “Let me put you in touch! I’ll look out for opportunities” sentences?
Perhaps fewer than we’d like to admit.
There is another issue: kind words may sometimes be the wrong remedy.
In Pretty Woman’s final scene, the voiceover entreats us to “keep on dreamin’… Always time to dream, so keep on dreamin’”.
But sometimes, the best advice is to change the dream.
The best advice I heard in my conversations at PRI in Person: “Ask me what would help.”
I realised when writing this op-ed that I interpret being an ally as affirming dreams. To respond to pitches with constructive feedback about how to improve them. To dispense encouraging affirmation when people tell me about the consultancy they are launching (real or fronts while they look for gainful employment) or a venture they are scaffolding.
Sometimes I am genuinely excited. But quite often, in my heart of hearts, I think the attempt is ill-fated.
Doesn’t make me right, of course, but am I actually an ally in those moments? Or a coward?
We are in an industry that – at the moment – has more people wanting to work in it than jobs. And that means some people should focus on a career change, rather than keep trying to get back on that horse that has bucked them off once too often.
The best advice I heard in my conversations at PRI in Person: “Ask me what would help.”
What does the person need at that moment? Words of affirmation? Harsh truths? A specific door that perhaps only you can open? Ideas and feedback?
Sometimes it feels like we have collectively decided to engage in a type of omertà on this topic. And that includes not asking our cherished friends and acquaintances facing brutal economic headwinds what would help most.
That is at least the vibe I got in my conversations in Amsterdam.
So, perhaps we can channel our best stakeholder manager impression and actually consult on what would be useful. We are sustainability professionals after all.
Not asking what would help is, of course, the mistake the shopkeepers made on Rodeo Drive when they took Vivian for a woman without means.
And we all know how that ended: “Big mistake. Big. Huge.”
…I have to go be an ally now…